New York Mets vs New York Yankees: MLB Best Bets (5/18)

Sunday Night Baseball happens again tonight on ESPN to wrap up MLB’s rivalry weekend. We’ve got the Subway Series to end the week at Yankee Stadium as the New York Mets take on the New York Yankees in Game 3. This is the first meeting between both squads this year, and we only see them meet once more in early July at Citi Field.

The Yankees were able to win on Friday, beating their visitors 6-2, but the Mets got their revenge the next day. It was a low scoring affair, but three runs was all the Mets needed in order to take down their hosts, 3-2, to even things up. Now they face off once again to close out this series on national television, giving someone bragging rights for the next two months before they meet again.

Will the Yankees bounce back and win this series tonight? Or will the Mets string together a second straight win against their big brother?

Check out our Expert MLB Picks!

New York Mets vs New York Yankees: Sunday Night Baseball

Matchup Information – Mets vs Yankees

• Venue & Location: Yankee Stadium (Bronx, NY)
• Date: Sunday, May 18, 2025
• First Pitch: 7:00 p.m. Eastern
• Broadcast: ESPN

Pitching Matchup

• New York Mets: David Peterson (2-2, 3.05 ERA, 1.35 WHIP)
• New York Yankees: Max Fried (6-0, 1.11 ERA, 0.94 WHIP)

Betting Odds

Odds are courtesy of BetOnline, and industry leader in the sports betting world. BetOnline offers a wide variety of markets paired with the most competitive lines available, making them the go to site to place your bets. Sign up today with Promo Code FREE250 and get a 50% deposit match up to $250, as well as 100 Free Spins in the online casino.

Check out the Best USA Sportsbooks here!

Run Line

• Mets +1.5 (-140)
• Yankees -1.5 (+120)

Moneyline

• Mets +141
• Yankees -156

Total

• Over 9 (-118)
• Under 9 (-102)

Two lefties take the mound for either team tonight, and looking at the splits, this should help both teams at the plate. The Yankees hit .262 as a team with that dropping to .251 over the month of May. However, against LHP their batting average leaps to .277. The same goes for the visitors, who hit .250 overall, and .262 against lefties. Plus, the Mets’ average is also up to .259 during the month of May. Point being, in a hitter’s park, on national TV, I think we might be in for some fireworks.

New York Mets vs New York Yankees Best Bets

Mets vs Yankees Prediction: Yankees Win, Over 9

Best Bets: Over 9 (-118) BetOnline

One of these days, this is going to hit. I have been waiting for the juiced balls to come out on Sunday Night all season long, as the under 9 is 6-1 so far this year. However, it’s the Yankees, it’s the Mets, and we’re on ESPN. Just put on the tinfoil hat and root for runs with me tonight.

Both games have gone under in this series so far and throughout Sunday Night Baseball, but these pitcher’s are due for a blow up game. David Peterson has allowed multiple earned runs in 6/8 starts this year, and has two road losses as well. The Yankees haven’t seen him much, but I am betting on the hitter’s having the advantage tonight. As for the hosts, Max Fried has been insane. The guy is 6-0 on the bump, leads the league in ERA, and is also Top 10 in WHIP.

However, he’s given up nine hits in his last two starts (12 IP), but that’s translated to just one earned run in each outing. While I don’t necessarily see the Mets putting up multiple runs against the Yankee’s starter, they shouldn’t need to contribute very many in this game. I trust both New York teams to come out red hot at the plate, giving the fans a show in this series finale.

Still Didn’t Get Your MLB Fix?

Here at Betting News, we offer Free Expert Picks for every major sports league. We also host daily streams on our Twitch Channel with our best bets, as well as sweat out games on Playback! Be sure to tune into everything we have going on at our Youtube, TikTok, and X pages as well.

For more MLB action, check out these pages below.

• MLB Best Bets Today
• AL & NL Cy Young Awards
• World Series Odds

Check Out All of Our Resources at Betting News